AI-written summary of reporting by BBC News. No human editor reviewed this. AI can misread or omit facts — read the original, linked below.
ABSTRACT

The Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH) has published a systematic review of approximately 81 studies on vaping, finding associations between e-cigarette use and respiratory problems, nicotine dependence, and harm in babies born to mothers who vaped during pregnancy, and has called on the UK government to impose stricter restrictions on the products.

UK doctors call for tighter vaping restrictions after review links e-cigarettes to child health harms

UK doctors call for tighter vaping restrictions after review links e-cigarettes to child health harms

The Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH) has published a systematic review of approximately 81 studies on vaping, finding associations between e-cigarette use and respiratory problems, nicotine dependence, and harm in babies born to mothers who vaped during pregnancy, and has called on the UK government to impose stricter restrictions on the products.

Context

The review, published in the journal Archives of Disease in Childhood, examined studies covering health and social outcomes of vaping on children and young people. It identified associations with wheezing, coughing, poor oral and dental health, poor sleep, mental health problems, and eye symptoms.

The RCPCH is urging the government to go beyond its current proposals and limit the types of flavours available in vaping products, rather than only regulating how those flavours are described on packaging.

In July, the UK government launched a 12-week consultation on the appearance, packaging, and display of vapes, aimed at reducing their appeal to children. Under the proposed rules, packs would need to be plain with strict limits on branding, with only simple flavour descriptions permitted, and vapes would be moved out of sight in shops, similar to current rules for cigarettes and tobacco.

The consultation follows the passing of the Tobacco and Vapes Act, which creates what the government describes as the UK's first smoke-free generation by making it permanently illegal to sell tobacco to anyone born after 1 January 2009. According to a poll conducted for the charity Action on Smoking and Health (Ash), almost one in five 11-to-17-year-olds in Britain have tried vaping.

All Perspectives
RCPCH co-author Prof Will Carroll: Carroll said the evidence showed 'clear links' with respiratory symptoms, nicotine dependence, and subsequent cigarette smoking, and called on the government 'to go further and limit the types of flavours available to them as opposed to just their descriptions.' He said: 'We must act to make vaping less attractive and accessible to children.'
RCPCH Vice-President Dr Mike McKean: McKean said: 'Vaping is still a relatively new product, and there is much we do not yet know about its long-term impact on children and young people but a clear and concerning picture is emerging.' He described the Tobacco and Vapes Act as 'an important step towards protecting children from nicotine addiction, but it must not be seen as a one-and-done solution.' He also said: 'We need to keep pace with a rapidly evolving market and continue to take action to protect children from nicotine products.'
Ash chief executive Hazel Cheeseman: Cheeseman said: 'The evidence remains clear that vaping is less harmful than smoking but is not risk free.' She added: 'As it was with tobacco, strong controls on marketing and promotion will be key to reducing youth vaping.'
Asthma + Lung UK (Andrew McCracken): McCracken said: 'Vapes can play an important role for current smokers looking to quit, but anyone who doesn't smoke, shouldn't vape, and that is especially true for children.'
UK Department of Health and Social Care: A spokesperson said 'children should never vape and this evidence shows just some of the risks associated,' and noted the government 'have already banned single-use vapes and have legislated to ban advertising and sponsorship from next year too,' adding that it is 'also consulting on proposals to crack down on packaging that appeals to children.'
Position not represented in the source reporting: Vaping industry or e-cigarette manufacturers.
Gaps & Unknowns
  • The source does not state the sample sizes, age ranges, or methodologies of the approximately 81 studies reviewed.
  • The source does not specify what proportion of the studies were conducted in the UK as opposed to other countries.
  • The source does not state whether the systematic review was itself peer-reviewed prior to publication.
  • The source does not detail the precise birth rates or prevalence figures for the harms identified in babies born to mothers who vaped during pregnancy.
  • The source does not provide the full polling methodology or margin of error for the Ash survey of 11-to-17-year-olds.
  • The source does not state when the government's 12-week consultation is expected to conclude or when any resulting regulations would take effect.
Sources & Further Reading
  1. BBC News — original

Read the original at BBC News

Related Coverage