Teddi Mellencamp, 45, publicly identified financial analyst PJ Conley, 31, as her romantic partner on Tuesday, tagging him in an Instagram slideshow from John Mellencamp's Hollywood Bowl concert and referring to herself as a 'cougar' in the caption.
Teddi Mellencamp publicly introduces boyfriend PJ Conley, 31, at father's Hollywood Bowl concert
Teddi Mellencamp, 45, publicly identified financial analyst PJ Conley, 31, as her romantic partner on Tuesday, tagging him in an Instagram slideshow from John Mellencamp's Hollywood Bowl concert and referring to herself as a 'cougar' in the caption.
The Instagram carousel included a video of Mellencamp and Conley together, a selfie of the couple, and photos with friends including Kyle Richards and her children, whom she shares with estranged husband Edwin Arroyave, 49.
On her 'Two Ts in a Pod' podcast the following day, Mellencamp said Conley 'got along effortlessly with the fam, my brother, my sisters,' and described him as 'cute' and 'funny' to guest co-host Dolores Catania.
Mellencamp said her father John Mellencamp, 74, briefly met Conley at the event but did not comment immediately — she said she 'kept it moving.' The elder Mellencamp later asked his daughter, 'You gonna try to tell me that wasn't your guy you introduced me to?'
Mellencamp said she had been referring to Conley by the nickname 'Valley Guy' on her podcast for months. She clarified Wednesday that 'he's not from this valley, but his hometown has a valley in it, so it still counts.' Conley's LinkedIn profile states he graduated from Utah Valley University in 2020.
Conley had not posted about the relationship on his own Instagram account as of the time of the report. Mellencamp told podcast listeners ahead of the Tuesday event that Arroyave and Conley were expected to meet, saying, 'I think they're gonna be fine. I think the fact that we're all doing this is good.'
Mellencamp is currently in remission from stage 4 cancer. She was previously linked to producer Ricci Rea in 2025, and was alleged to have had an affair with her married horse trainer, Simon Schroeder, in 2024 — the same year her separation from Arroyave became public. She and Arroyave, who married in July 2011, have remained on amicable terms during their divorce proceedings, with Arroyave described as supportive during her health struggles.
- The source does not state whether Arroyave and Conley did in fact meet at the Tuesday event.
- The source does not state Conley's response or his own characterization of the relationship.
- The source does not specify the nature or current status of Mellencamp's divorce proceedings beyond describing them as ongoing.
- The source does not state what stage 4 cancer Mellencamp was diagnosed with or when her remission was confirmed.
- The source does not state whether the alleged affair with Simon Schroeder was ever legally adjudicated or formally denied by the parties.
Read the original at New York Post