Republican Rep. Massie files articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Hegseth over Iran war

Republican Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky introduced articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Tuesday, reading the text aloud on the House floor in Washington and accusing Hegseth of violating the 1973 War Powers Resolution by carrying out hostilities against Iran without congressional authorization. Massie filed the measure as privileged, meaning the House must take it up within two legislative days — by Thursday, according to CBS News, The Guardian, NPR and the Washington Post. Massie lost his primary in May to a challenger backed by President Donald Trump and is not seeking reelection. The resolution is widely described as unlikely to pass in a Republican-controlled Congress, but it could force a floor vote ahead of the November midterm elections.

Massie's resolution outlines eight alleged constitutional violations by Hegseth, according to CBS News and The Guardian. The articles accuse Hegseth of attacking Iran without seeking Congress's permission, defying a war powers resolution, ignoring laws intended to minimize civilian casualties, retaliating against Democratic Sen. Mark Kelly of Arizona after Kelly urged service members to refuse illegal orders, and carrying out "extrajudicial killings" in boat strikes in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific, the capture of former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro, and a bombing campaign in Yemen. The Washington Post reported that Massie argued Hegseth violated three provisions of the War Powers Resolution of 1973. In a floor statement, Massie said Hegseth had acted "in a manner contrary to his trust as Secretary of Defense and subversive of constitutional government."

The sources describe the War Powers Resolution's requirements differently. CBS News said the law requires the administration to report to Congress within 48 hours of deploying forces into hostilities absent a declaration of war, caps unauthorized engagement at 60 days with an additional 30-day withdrawal window, and reported Massie's argument that Congress did not authorize or extend the 60-day period. The New York Post said the resolution requires congressional authorization for military operations lasting longer than 90 days, and The Guardian quoted Massie saying Hegseth engaged in hostilities "for more than 90 days without congressional authorization."

The timeline of the conflict is also described differently. The New York Post said the Iran war began Feb. 28; the Jerusalem Post said the war began with Feb. 28 attacks on Iran by US and Israeli forces; CBS News said the war began in late February, that the administration has said the initial operation, called Operation Epic Fury, ended in early May, and that Trump notified Congress on July 10 that "military action" against Iran had formally restarted after he declared a monthlong ceasefire over. The New York Post reported the White House argues the conflict ended after an initial phase of fighting, resetting the 90-day clock, and that a ceasefire in place since April 8 and a memorandum of understanding signed by Trump on June 17 crumbled in July when Iran attacked commercial ships using a US-preferred route in the Strait of Hormuz.

On congressional action, The Guardian reported the House and Senate approved a war powers resolution in June that would require an end to the conflict. CBS News reported the House approved several measures to limit Trump's power to strike Iran but that most failed to advance in the GOP-led Senate. The New York Post said the House and Senate passed resolutions earlier this year calling on Trump to end the Iran war. The Guardian reported that if the resolution passed, the articles would go to the Senate, where Republican leadership would decide whether to hold a trial.

Massie has clashed repeatedly with his own party, and all six sources note his role in forcing the release of federal files related to Jeffrey Epstein. The Jerusalem Post reported he lost his May primary to Ed Gallrein, a former Navy SEAL backed by Trump and by heavy spending from pro-Israel groups, after leading a push to release Justice Department files tied to Epstein. The Guardian and NPR reported the war has grown unpopular with the public and contributed to rising costs in the United States. The Jerusalem Post cited a Reuters/Ipsos poll released Monday showing Democrats leading Republicans 44% to 37% in congressional vote preference ahead of the Nov. 3 elections.

NPR reported the administration maintains the conflict was necessary to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon, while experts maintain the country was not close to developing one before the conflict began six months ago. The Guardian reported the resolution cites a US strike on a school in Minab, Iran that killed more than 168 people; CBS News reported Massie accused Hegseth of ignoring laws to minimize civilian casualties, specifically mentioning the bombing of a girls' school in Iran shortly after the war began, and that a preliminary assessment in March found the US was "likely" responsible for the strike but did not intentionally target the school.

Where sources differ

• Scope of the resolution: CBS News and The Guardian report eight articles of impeachment; the Washington Post reports Massie argued Hegseth violated three provisions of the War Powers Resolution of 1973.
• War Powers Resolution deadline: CBS News describes a 60-day cap on unauthorized hostilities plus a 30-day withdrawal window; the New York Post says the law requires congressional authorization for operations lasting longer than 90 days, and The Guardian quotes Massie citing more than 90 days.
• Congressional action on the war: The Guardian says the House and Senate approved a war powers resolution in June that would require an end to the conflict; CBS News says the House approved several limiting measures but most failed to advance in the GOP-led Senate; the New York Post says both chambers passed resolutions earlier this year calling on Trump to end the war.
• Status of the conflict: CBS News reports the administration said the initial operation ended in early May and that Trump notified Congress on July 10 that military action had formally restarted; the New York Post reports the White House argues the conflict ended after an initial phase, resetting the 90-day clock.
• Minab school strike: The Guardian reports the strike killed more than 168 people; CBS News reports a March preliminary assessment found the US was "likely" responsible but did not intentionally target the school, without giving a death toll.
• Department name: the Jerusalem Post and CBS News refer to the Department of Defense and Defense Secretary; the New York Post, NPR and Pentagon statements refer to the Department of War and Secretary of War.

• No source reports the outcome of the House vote or whether the resolution will pass.
• No source quotes Hegseth himself; his direct response to the allegations is not included.
• No source reports whether Senate Republican leadership would hold a trial if the articles passed the House.
• No source includes a response from the Iranian government or from any Democratic lawmaker on the resolution.
• The death toll of the Minab school strike is given only by The Guardian (more than 168), while CBS News cites a preliminary assessment that did not provide a figure.
• No source establishes whether Iran was close to developing a nuclear weapon before the conflict, beyond competing claims by the administration and experts.
• No source reports a response from House Republican leadership to Massie's filing.

1. The Jerusalem Post — original — by REUTERS
2. CBS News — by Caroline Linton
3. Washington Post Politics — by Anna Liss-Roy
4. The Guardian US — by Chris Stein in Washington
5. NPR News — by Eric McDaniel
6. New York Post — by Steven Nelson

Read the original at The Jerusalem Post

• Titans fan account retracts pledge to walk nearly 900 miles to MetLife Stadium
• Republican Sens. Moreno and Banks oppose Senate inquiry into Trump Jr. over Russian-funded wedding party
• Bentley unveils Torcal, its first fully electric vehicle, priced from £173,000
• UK Conservatives propose cutting Universal Credit by 30% for long-term unemployed
• NYPD says cameras captured three men emerging from sewers near Netanyahu's planned New York hotel
• Draft statement attributed to Rubio condemning UK, France and Canada settlement-import bans was never released