AI-written summary of reporting by ABC News Australia. No human editor reviewed this. AI can misread or omit facts — read the original, linked below.
ABSTRACT

Savers opened its 19th Australian store in Geelong on August 27, drawing a queue stretching roughly 100 metres, as local charity operators raised concerns that the US-backed for-profit retailer competes directly with non-profit op shops for donated goods and customers.

For-profit thrift chain Savers opens 19th Australian store, drawing scrutiny from local charities

For-profit thrift chain Savers opens 19th Australian store, drawing scrutiny from local charities

Savers opened its 19th Australian store in Geelong on August 27, drawing a queue stretching roughly 100 metres, as local charity operators raised concerns that the US-backed for-profit retailer competes directly with non-profit op shops for donated goods and customers.

Context

Savers Australia is a subsidiary of Savers Value Village (SVV), a company listed on the New York Stock Exchange with a market value of $2.2 billion and a majority stake held by American private equity firm Ares Management. SVV is described as North America's largest for-profit second-hand retailer, with 185 stores in the United States and 172 in Canada. The company reported earnings of more than $300 million last year, according to Refinitiv data, and carries a gross profit margin of 50 per cent.

Savers' business model in Australia involves partnering with non-profit organisations, which collect donated goods from the public and deliver them to Savers stores in exchange for payment. At the Geelong opening, donation bins bearing Diabetes Victoria's branding were on display. Diabetes Victoria chief executive Glen Noonan, who attended the launch, said the arrangement allows his organisation to raise revenue from second-hand donations without operating shops itself, though he declined to disclose the specific payment terms, describing them as confidential.

Analytics firm IBISWorld noted that larger retailers including Savers have 'consistently outperformed their smaller, non-employing counterparts' in the Australian second-hand retail market, 'primarily owing to their capacity to harness economies of scale.'

In North America, SVV has been deploying an artificial-intelligence-backed pricing tool called ThriftIQ to speed up pricing decisions and improve stock sell-through. UBS retail analyst Michael Lasser, whose bank has done work for Savers, said the technology leads to 'better pricing of products, more productive use of labour, and faster sell-through of the goods.' Savers declined to say whether ThriftIQ would be extended to its Australian stores.

SVV's plan for 2026 includes opening around 25 new stores globally, more than 20 of which will be in the United States across 11 states. Savers Australia boss Michael Fisher said the company would open at least one further Australian store in the coming year, though he did not specify a location. Savers currently employs 1,250 staff across stores in New South Wales, Victoria, and South Australia.

All Perspectives
Savers Australia (Michael Fisher, local boss): Fisher said: 'I'm sorry to hear those concerns because [at] Savers, it's important to us to make sure that we grow in the circular economy. In Australia and globally, we partner with not-for-profit organisations. They go and solicit donations from the general public, they bring them to the stores, and we pay them for those donations. So if you donate to us at the store, you're actually donating to the not-for-profit, and we pay them for that.' He added that the company is 'really excited with the growth of second-hand across Australia' and confirmed at least one more Australian store opening is planned.
Norlane Community House (Esther Koning-Oakes, charity operator): Koning-Oakes, who runs the Treasures op shop in Geelong, said: 'We should be keeping as much as what we can in Australia.' She expressed concern that Savers' presence would reduce customers and donations for her charity, adding: 'I think a lot of people, when they donate things, they want to donate it for a good cause. Having it for a for-profit company means that that is going into shareholders or upper management, and it doesn't actually go back into community.'
Diabetes Victoria (Glen Noonan, chief executive): Noonan, present at the Geelong opening, said the millions Diabetes Victoria received from Savers last year were beneficial and allowed the organisation to generate revenue from second-hand donations without the burden of running shops. 'From the revenue that we generate, we provide much-needed services to Victorians,' he said. He declined to disclose the specific payment terms of the arrangement.
UBS retail analyst (Michael Lasser): Lasser described Savers as 'a business that is aimed at more effectively monetising the donated goods for charities' and said its biggest overheads would be staff wages, store overheads, and the undisclosed cost of buying used items. On ThriftIQ, he said it 'leads to better pricing of products, more productive use of labour, and faster sell-through of the goods' and that it is 'just in the process of rolling out.'
Savers customer at Geelong opening (unnamed): One woman in the queue said she would shop at Savers but would not donate goods there: 'I will not be donating my clothes here. I would rather give back to the Salvation Army or the Geelong Animal Welfare Society.'
Position not represented in the source reporting: Vinnies and Salvos — named as direct competitors affected by Savers' expansion but not contacted for comment in the source.
Gaps & Unknowns
  • The source does not state the specific payment rates Savers offers non-profit partners per kilogram or item of donated goods.
  • The source does not state what proportion of unsold merchandise ends up in landfill, is exported to the rag trade, or is recycled.
  • The source does not state whether Savers' Australian revenue or profit figures are disclosed separately from its global accounts.
  • The source does not state the locations under consideration for Savers' next Australian store opening.
  • The source does not state the basis on which SVV's $2.2 billion valuation figure was calculated or the date on which it was recorded.
  • The source does not state whether Diabetes Victoria's arrangement with Savers is exclusive or whether other non-profits hold similar contracts in the same regions.
Sources & Further Reading
  1. ABC News Australia — original

Read the original at ABC News Australia

Related Coverage